INDEPENDENT PERSPECTIVES ON WHOLE-PERSON HEALTHSearch the Journal ↗
Wholistic Health Journal
NEWS, PROVIDERS, AND DESTINATIONS FOR WHOLE-PERSON HEALTH
Sections & searchAll news & research
News
Health & Wellness TopicsFind a ProviderFeatured Providers by StateWellness DestinationsGet MatchedFor ProvidersSearch

Research explainer

One Drink a Day, Two Trials and a Question About What Lasts

A masked school beverage study and a home-delivery trial in teenagers found differences in weight gain during treatment. The longer follow-up complicates the picture.

Wholistic Health Journal ·

White sugar cubes on a black surface.
White sugar cubes on a black surface.
Poyraz 72 · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Cropped to 8:5, resized and converted to WebP.

A school drink with a measured difference

In a Dutch trial, schools distributed a small drink each day to children who had been assigned by chance to one of two groups. The drinks were designed to taste alike. One contained sugar and supplied 104 calories per serving. The other used a noncaloric sweetener. The experiment narrowed a difficult nutrition question to a substitution that families and researchers could identify precisely. There was no need to reconstruct from memory the sugar content of a succession of different brands or serving sizes. The question was whether changing that one drink could produce a measurable difference as children grew.

Growth over eighteen months

The study enrolled 641 children, most of whom started at a normal weight. Both groups gained weight, as would be expected during childhood. The estimated average gain was 6.35 kilograms in the sugar-free group and 7.37 kilograms in the sugar group. Measures including skinfold thickness also favored the sugar-free group. One qualification deserves attention. About a quarter of the children stopped taking the study drinks, and the main analysis estimated missing measurements. A separate analysis that included available measurements from children who had stopped found a smaller difference in the age-adjusted body mass index measure. The uncertainty around that estimate included the possibility of no difference.

A delivery at home

A second research team started in a different place. Its 224 participants were adolescents with overweight or obesity who regularly drank sugary beverages. Families in the intervention group received help replacing these drinks, including a supply of noncaloric beverages at home. At the end of one year the groups differed in weight gain and change in body mass index. Then the deliveries and organized intervention ended. The main outcome specified in advance was the change in body mass index at two years. At that point the researchers could no longer distinguish the groups with statistical confidence.

The calendar changes the question

The school study examined a daily substitution while a distribution system was in place. The adolescent trial also examined what happened after a family lost that support. Those are different decisions for a school or community considering a beverage program. Neither comparison establishes which alternative drink is best for a particular child. Taken together, the studies give a concrete reason to ask how long a proposed change in access will last and at what point its effects will be measured.

Sources & references

Photo: Poyraz 72 · CC BY-SA 4.0

Continue exploring

Related topic · Find a provider · Explore destinations

Stay informed